OVERVIEW:
Date: September 13 2022
Location: Wits Club at the University of the Witwatersrand, Johannesburg, South Africa
Programme:https://journalism.co.za/wp-content/uploads/2022/09/Final-Programme-Ajen-round-table-Sept22-v4.pdf
Keynote: Dr Hayes Mabweazara, University of Glasgow
The African Journalism Education Network’s inaugural roundtable meeting which took place in Johannesburg, South Africa on September 2022 brought together almost 40 journalism teachers from 25 institutions across the continent with around half attending physically and the rest online. Some 15 countries from across the continent were represented, as well as some from as far afield as Argentina, Bangladesh and France.
The meeting featured almost 20 speakers and four panel discussions on topics ranging from ways to improve journalism education on the continent and the pitfalls and opportunities of campus publication to decoloniality and language, research priorities and other issues.
In his keynote address, University of Glasgow’s Dr Hayes Mabweazara, said journalism faced “crises and challenges” that “point to an increasingly complex ecosystem of journalism in which the hegemony of traditional mainstream news media as the sole arbiters of news is under unprecedented threat”.
He said the profession faced a crisis of a normative identity rooted in Anglo-American conceptions of journalism. There was also the issue of the impact of technology on journalism, among which the challenges and threats posed by “peripheral news actors … at the edges of the journalistic field, (who) have ‘openly’ challenged the traditional forms of journalism”. These “interlopers” raise questions on the field should be extended to include them, he said.
Alternative forms of journalisms could be seen as responding to Africa’s socio-political fabric. Drawing on a range of studies, he said new forms included music and art as journalism; jokes and comedy; and the interplay between satire and investigative journalism (as in Nigeria). Satire performs the watchdog role of journalism by calling the powerful to account through humour and jokes – “the lines between satirical journalism and mainstream journalism keep blurring”, Dr Mabweazara said.
These and other factors had implications for journalism education, he said, including a need for:
- Critical digital pedagogy/literacy that stretches beyond skills to include understanding of the complexity of the media ecosystems that are in constant flux.
- A bold and assertive foregrounding of contextually-rooted communication practices drawn from lived experiences.
- Engagement with the work of interlopers/peripheral actors and in so doing build towards offering a way to differentiate between interlopers and setting field boundaries.
“In the midst of all the cacophony and complex news media ecosystems, it is not too difficult to see the centrality and continued relevance of strong public service media”, because of questions of social inequalities in access to information, the pervasive nature of disinformation on social media and various other forms of dark participation, he added.
Catia Mangue from Mozambique’s Media Lab told the gathering that there were only four universities teaching journalism in that country. These were in urban areas, which created a scenario where journalism in rural areas was poorly practiced. The journalism education curriculum was very theoretical, she said, with no African concepts being taught. Rather, Brazilian, Portuguese and English models were used even though they did not “follow the reality of Mozambique”, said Mangue.
University of Eswatini’s Siphiwe Mahomed told the gathering that training in public relations attracted most students than journalism in her institution. There was a challenge in Eswatini to restore the credibility of journalism.
Mauritius National University’s Christina Chan-Meetoo told the roundtable that her institution was working to strengthen the usage of Creole as an indigenous language as French and English have dominated the country’s media.
In Kenya, said Prof Nancy Booker from Nairobi’s Aga Khan University, news organisations were concerned about the job readiness of journalism graduates. They were expected to “hit the road running”, which made it necessary for journalism education to be harmonized with newsroom work.
In this regard, suggestions were made for a meeting of journalism educators and industry leaders to be organized to discuss ways to support the profession.
Among suggestions for joint projects were a continental survey to determine where journalism graduates go after completing their studies, and the development of African textbooks for journalism schools.
Plans for Ajen:
It was agreed that Ajen should remain an informal network for the present, but the meeting elected a steering committee of five members, representing Southern East and West Africa. They are Prof Franz Krüger from the Wits Centre for Journalism, Dr Sisanda Nkoala from Cape Peninsula University of Technology, Dr Modestus Fosu from the Ghana Institute of Journalism and Dr Basil Hamusokwe from the University of Zambia.
Panel at SACOMM 2022:
Following the roundtable meeting, Ajen hosted a panel discussion at the annual
South African Communications Association (SACOMM) conference which took place on September 14 – 16 2022 at the University of Witwatersrand.
The panel on “Journalism teaching in Africa: digital tools and challenges” held on September 15 was chaired by Dr Franz Krüger of the Wits Centre for Journalism. The panellists, Dr Theodora Dame Adjin-Tettey, Prof Anthea Garman, and Prof Margaret Jjuuko discussed what a new normal may look like in the use of digital technologies in teaching, with respect to the teaching of digital media skills and how to remain relevant in a field that has been placed under severe strain by the growing dominance of digital platforms based in the Global North.
The three speakers reflected on how African journalism education faces challenges that range from the legacy of colonialism to the impact of digital disruption on already constrained media environments. The discussion included a focus on how the COVID-19 pandemic and attendant infodemic exacerbated these challenges, not least by forcing journalism schools to adopt remote teaching modes and the use of digital teaching tools.
Read our post-meeting reports of the 2022 Ajen roundtable: